After 7 years, renting comes out ahead
If you buy
$212,676
Net proceeds after selling
If you rent
$239,677
Down payment invested + monthly difference
Difference
$27,002
In favor of renting
Building enough equity to beat renting takes about 6 years under these assumptions. Plan on staying at least that long.
Monthly cost to own
$3,288
PITI + maintenance + HOA
Monthly cost to rent
$2,425
Year one
Ownership premium
$863
Owning costs more today
Where the ownership cost goes
Equity versus what renting leaves you
Cumulative cost, year by year
| Year | Buy cost / yr | Rent cost / yr | Home value | Equity | Loan balance |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $39,455 | $29,100 | $465,750 | $109,774 | $355,976 |
| 2 | $39,881 | $30,252 | $482,051 | $130,368 | $351,683 |
| 3 | $40,321 | $31,450 | $498,923 | $151,821 | $347,102 |
| 4 | $40,776 | $32,696 | $516,385 | $174,171 | $342,214 |
| 5 | $41,248 | $33,992 | $534,459 | $197,459 | $337,000 |
| 6 | $41,736 | $35,340 | $553,165 | $221,730 | $331,435 |
| 7 | $42,241 | $36,741 | $572,526 | $247,027 | $325,498 |
This model invests the monthly difference between the two choices at the return rate you entered and compares what each path leaves you with at the end of the period. Property tax, insurance and maintenance are charged against the home's value each year, so they rise as the home appreciates; some states cap assessment growth below that. It ignores moving costs, the value of flexibility and any rent control that may apply where you live.
Powered by Rent vs Buy Calculator — FigureCrunch