FigureCrunch

Guide, 8 min read, updated November 15, 2026

PMI: what it really costs and the two ways it disappears

How private mortgage insurance is priced, when your servicer must cancel it, and how to avoid paying it at all.

Private mortgage insurance — PMI — is the premium you pay when you buy a home with less than 20% down on a conventional loan. It protects the lender, not you, against the risk that a low-down-payment borrower defaults early in the loan. That is the part most buyers know. What fewer buyers know is that PMI is temporary by law, cancels itself at a fixed point, and can often be removed years earlier than the default schedule.

What PMI actually costs

PMI is quoted as an annual percentage of the loan balance, collected monthly as part of your mortgage payment. Rates run from about 0.3% to 1.5% per year, driven mainly by your down payment and credit score:

  • 15% down with a 780 credit score might pay 0.3% or less — barely noticeable in the payment.
  • 5% down with a 660 credit score can pay 1% or more — often hundreds of dollars a month on a typical balance.

A common planning figure is 0.5%–0.6%. On a $450,000 home purchased with 10% down — a $405,000 loan — 0.55% per year works out to about $186 per month. Over the roughly nine years PMI would normally last on a 30-year schedule, that is about $20,000. Run your own numbers in the mortgage calculator, which includes PMI in the monthly payment and marks the cancellation month on the amortization table.

The two automatic cancellation rules

The Homeowners Protection Act of 1998 sets two milestones. Both are measured against the original value of the home at closing — the purchase price or appraised value, whichever is lower — not against a later appraisal.

  • 80% — request it. Once your balance falls to 80% of the original value on the scheduled amortization, you can ask in writing to cancel. The servicer must comply if you are current on the loan and have a clean recent payment history.
  • 78% — automatic. The servicer must cancel PMI on its own once the scheduled balance reaches 78% of the original value, assuming you are current. This is the floor: no request needed, the charge simply stops.

On a 30-year fixed loan with 10% down, the automatic cancellation arrives around year nine of the schedule. With 5% down it takes longer — often past year eleven. Every extra dollar of principal you pay pulls both milestones closer.

Getting PMI off early: the current-value route

The two statutory milestones use the original value, but servicers may also cancel based on current value in two situations:

  • Borrower-requested appraisal: if your home has appreciated, or you have paid the balance down aggressively, you can request an appraisal-based removal. Rules vary — many servicers require the loan to be at least two years old for appreciation alone, but waive the seasoning if the balance is already at or below 80% of the new value purely from principal reduction.
  • Substantial improvement: a renovation that raises the value (a new kitchen, an addition) counts toward the new appraised value in the same request.

The appraisal costs a few hundred dollars and typically must be done by the servicer's chosen appraiser — not one you hire yourself. If the new value pushes your LTV to 80% or below, PMI ends; the servicer tells you the effective date.

What PMI is not

PMI applies to conventional loans only. Other loan types carry their own insurance with very different rules:

  • FHA loans charge Mortgage Insurance Premiums. With the minimum 3.5% down, MIP now lasts for the life of the loan — the only exit is refinancing into a conventional loan once you reach 20% equity. This is the single biggest difference buyers miss when comparing FHA against a low-down-payment conventional loan.
  • VA loans have a one-time funding fee and no monthly mortgage insurance at all.
  • USDA loans carry guarantee fees that, like FHA, generally last the life of the loan.

Avoiding PMI without 20% down

If waiting to save a full 20% is not realistic — and in a rising market it often costs more in appreciation than it saves in PMI — three structures avoid the monthly premium:

  • Piggyback second mortgage (80-10-10): an 80% first mortgage, a 10% second mortgage or HELOC, and 10% down. The second mortgage carries a higher rate, and the combination only beats PMI when the second loan is paid off relatively quickly.
  • Lender-paid PMI (LPMI): the lender pays the premium and charges you a higher interest rate instead. It removes the separate line item but costs more if you keep the loan past the point PMI would have cancelled — and unlike borrower-paid PMI, it never drops off.
  • Community or state first-time-buyer programs: many offer down payment assistance or PMI-free structures; income limits apply.

The honest comparison is total cost over the time you expect to keep the home. PMI that cancels in four years can be cheaper than a rate bump that lasts thirty.

Watch the calendar, not the balance alone

Servicers are reliable about the automatic 78% cancellation, but the earlier 80% request is on you — nobody sends a reminder. Two practical habits: check your annual escrow statement for the PMI line, and compare your current balance against 80% of the original value each year. When you get close, put the removal request in writing and keep a copy. After cancellation, verify the next statement actually drops the premium — mistakes happen, and they are easiest to fix in the first month.

Our mortgage calculator shows the exact month PMI cancels on your schedule, including the effect of extra monthly principal payments, and the refinance calculator models the other common exit: a refinance at a higher appraisal that starts the new loan at 80% LTV or better, with no PMI from day one.

Frequently asked questions

When does PMI cancel automatically?

Your servicer must cancel PMI automatically once your mortgage balance reaches 78% of the original home value (the price you paid or appraised value at closing, whichever was lower), provided you are current on payments. For a 30-year loan with 10% down, that happens around year nine on the normal amortization schedule.

Can I request PMI removal earlier?

Yes. Once your balance reaches 80% of the original value you can request removal in writing — the servicer must act on it if you are current and have a good payment history. You can also request removal early based on a new appraisal if home values have risen or you have made extra principal payments.

How much does PMI cost per month?

Typically between 0.3% and 1.5% of the loan balance per year, paid monthly. On a $405,000 loan at a common 0.55% rate, that is about $186 per month. The rate depends on your down payment, credit score and loan type — lower down payments and lower credit scores pay more.

Is PMI the same as FHA mortgage insurance?

No. FHA loans charge Mortgage Insurance Premiums (MIP), which in most cases last for the life of the loan and cannot be cancelled by reaching equity — only by refinancing out of the FHA program. Conventional-loan PMI, by contrast, ends automatically at 78% LTV.

Does making extra principal payments remove PMI faster?

Yes. Extra principal payments lower the balance faster, so you reach the 80% request threshold and the 78% automatic threshold sooner. You can also ask your servicer about a mid-schedule removal once you reach 80% based on the current balance rather than the original schedule.

Can I avoid PMI without 20% down?

Yes, the main options are a piggyback second mortgage (80-10-10 structure), lender-paid PMI where you accept a higher interest rate, or qualifying loan programs with no PMI requirement. Each trades the monthly PMI cost for a different cost, so compare the total expense over your expected holding period.

Run your own numbers

This guide is general information for planning purposes, not tax, legal or investment advice. Rules change and individual situations differ, so verify anything you plan to act on with the IRS instructions for your tax year or a qualified professional. Figures reflect the 2026 tax year unless stated otherwise.